Cites Google

AI Overviews Are Reshaping Nashville Law Firm SEO Strategy

6 min read

  • 5 sections
  • 1 table
  • 6 sources cited

AI Overviews change law firm SEO in one specific way: a page can keep its position and still lose clicks, because a summary above the results answers part of the question first. They do not change what Google uses to choose pages; Google says “There are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, nor other special optimizations necessary” (Google’s AI features documentation). For a Nashville firm, the strategy question is which of its queries are affected, and the data points to informational questions far more than to local hiring searches.

Ahrefs analyzed 146 million desktop search results from September 2025 (Ahrefs study of AI Overview triggers). Its figures for the categories that matter to a law firm:

Query group in the Ahrefs data Share of results with an AI Overview
All queries 20.5%
YMYL queries 34.3%
Legal YMYL queries 23.6%
Queries classified as local searches 7.9%

Two conclusions follow, both limited to this one data set. Legal questions are not shielded from AI Overviews; at 23.6%, they show them somewhat more often than the 20.5% average. And queries Ahrefs classified as local searches showed them far less often, at 7.9%; hiring searches such as “lawyer near me” look like that group, though the study does not list which queries it classed as local. Ahrefs also reports that 99% of AI Overviews in its data appeared on informational keywords.

For a firm, that splits the site in two. Practice area pages built for local hiring searches are, on this data, the less exposed half. Blog posts and guides that answer questions such as “how long do I have to file after a car accident in Tennessee” are the pages most exposed to a summary that answers before the click.

How Much an Overview Changes Clicks

Two studies measured the effect from different angles:

  • Ahrefs compared click-through rates for top-ranking pages in December 2023 and December 2025 and concluded: “As of December 2025, AI Overviews reduce the organic click-through rate for position one content by 58%” (Ahrefs click-through update). The study measures a correlation between the presence of an overview and lower click-through rates.
  • Pew Research Center tracked the browsing of 900 U.S. adults in March 2025. As reported by The Register, users who saw an AI summary clicked a traditional result in 8 percent of visits, against 15 percent for those who did not. Google disputed the study’s methodology in a statement to the publication.

Neither study is about law firms specifically, and the size of the effect on any one page has to come from that page’s own data.

Diagnosing a Page With Stable Rankings and Falling Clicks

Search Console now has two views to compare. The standard Performance report still counts traffic from AI features “within the “Web” search type.” Separately, Google introduced generative AI performance reports in a June 2026 Search Central post, first “rolling these reports out to a subset of websites” (Google’s announcement); the help page now notes: “As of August 31, 2026, we’ve rolled out these insights to all websites worldwide.” A site may still not see the report if it has not received enough impressions in these features. Google’s help page says the report shows “how many times links to your site were shown to a user in a generative AI feature on Google Search,” covering AI Overviews and AI Mode, grouped by page, country, device or date (Google’s generative AI performance report help). The help page describes impressions only; it does not describe click or query data for those features.

A diagnosis that uses both:

  1. In the Performance report, filter to the page and compare two equal periods, before and after the decline.
  2. Look at impressions for the page’s main queries. If impressions held steady while clicks and click-through rate fell, something on the results page may be taking clicks: an overview, a featured snippet, ads or a map pack.
  3. If the site has the generative AI report, check whether the page’s AI impressions rose over the same period. A rise alongside falling clicks supports the overview explanation; it does not prove it, because the report has no click data for comparison.
  4. If impressions fell along with clicks, look first at demand and ranking: whether fewer people searched, whether the page lost position for its main queries, and whether the mix of queries, countries or devices changed. An overview can still be part of the picture, so check the results page too.
  5. Search the main queries yourself, note the date, location and device, and record what appears above the first result.

Steps 2 and 3 together separate the explanations better than either alone. A stable position proves nothing by itself, because position in Search Console is an average across queries.

A Tennessee-Specific Check Worth Running

AI Overviews can draw on pages written for other states. For example, imagine a searcher asking how long they have to sue after a Nashville car crash. Tennessee’s answer starts with Tenn. Code Ann. § 28-3-104(a)(1): actions for “injuries to the person” must be commenced “within one (1) year after the cause of action accrued,” with a two-year period in defined situations involving criminal charges. An overview that blends in a two-year rule from another state would be wrong for a Tennessee reader.

Run the firm’s main informational questions with “Tennessee” in them and compare any overview with the statute or rule the firm’s own page cites. Where the overview is wrong or vague, the firm’s page has a reason to exist that the summary does not replace: the exact rule, its exceptions and who should check the deadline for the reader’s facts.

What to Change and What to Keep

Keep the fundamentals. Google’s documentation says that “To be eligible to be shown as a supporting link in AI Overviews or AI Mode, a page must be indexed and eligible to be shown in Google Search with a snippet,” so a page that fails in classic search has no separate path into an overview.

Change three things:

  • Measurement: report informational pages on impressions, AI feature impressions where the report is available, and the questions they rank for, not on clicks alone. How to widen reporting beyond clicks is covered in zero-click search for Nashville law firms.
  • Content priorities: put new effort where the data shows less overview exposure and more hiring intent, which is the practice area pages and the Business Profile, and make informational posts more specific to Tennessee than a summary can be.
  • Expectations: a blog post can be doing its job, being seen for the right question, while sending fewer visits than it did in 2023.

Whether an overview cites a firm’s page is a separate question from whether the page ranks; the evidence on how AI systems pick sources is reviewed in GEO for Nashville law firms.

The working rule for a Nashville firm is to protect the hiring pages and the profile first, and to judge informational content by whether it is found for the right questions, since that is the part of the site AI Overviews affect most.