Cites Google

SEO Competitor Analysis for Nashville Law Firms: Step by Step

5 min read

  • 6 sections
  • 2 tables
  • 3 sources cited

A competitor analysis answers one question: why does another firm appear above yours for the searches that bring clients, and which of the possible causes explains the gap? For a Nashville law firm there are two places to look, because a local legal search can show a map with Business Profiles as well as the regular results below it, and each runs on different signals. The steps below cover both, with the tool and the decision rule for each step.

Step 1: Choose the Queries and Record What Appears

Pick five to ten queries that bring the firm clients, using Search Console’s Queries report for what already works and intake notes for what clients say they searched. For each query, record two lists: the firms in the map and the firms in the first page of regular results. Reading what each query is really asking for is covered in keyword research for Nashville law firms.

Location changes both lists. Google says distance is “how far each business is from the customer who’s searching” (Google’s local ranking tips), so a search from downtown and a search from Franklin can show different firms. Run each query from the places the firm serves, or with a rank-tracking tool that sets the search location, and note where each result came from.

Decision rule: the competitors to analyze are the firms that appear repeatedly across the firm’s queries and locations, whether or not the firm thinks of them as rivals.

Step 2: Compare Business Profiles

For the map results, compare each competitor’s profile with the firm’s:

Item Where to look What a gap means
Primary and additional categories The category shown on each profile Google says "The categories you select affect your local ranking on Google"
Review count and rating The profiles themselves Google ties "how many reviews you have" and positive ratings to prominence
Distance Office addresses against the search location A gap here is about location, not quality
Completeness Hours, description, services, photos Google asks for "complete and detailed business info"

The category quote comes from Google’s category guidelines. Decision rule: if the competitor differs mainly on distance, the gap is geography and only a real office changes it; if it differs on category or reviews, those are the first things to address. Some details, such as a competitor’s full list of additional categories, may not be visible on the profile, so treat the comparison as partial. How Google combines these factors is covered in how Google chooses the map pack for Nashville law firms.

Step 3: Compare the Ranking Pages

For the regular results, open the competitor’s ranking page and the firm’s page for the same query and compare them section by section:

  • Does the competitor answer the question in the query directly, near the top?
  • Which client questions does it answer that the firm’s page does not: process, fees, timeline, Tennessee-specific rules?
  • Does it cite the statute or rule it relies on?
  • Is it the right type of page for the query, a practice page for a hiring search and an informational post for a question?

Decision rule: if the competitor’s page answers questions the firm’s page skips, the gap is content, and adding those answers is the fix. Length on its own is not the finding; the missing answers are. What a ranking practice page contains is described in why practice area pages fail to rank.

Search Console reports only on sites the firm has verified, so a competitor’s links have to come from a third-party link index, whose counts reflect that tool’s own crawl rather than Google’s. Compare:

  • which local organizations, publications, courts or bar groups link to the competitor’s site and not to the firm’s;
  • whether those links point to the ranking page or to the home page;
  • whether any look paid without being marked as sponsored.

Decision rule: if the competitor has links from local or legal sources the firm could earn through its own work, that is the link plan. Google also counts links toward local prominence, describing it as based on info “like how many websites link to your business.” Ways to earn those links within Google’s policies and Tennessee’s rules are in link building for Nashville law firms.

Step 5: Compare Technical Health and Attorney Pages

Two quick comparisons round out the picture:

  • Page experience: run both pages through PageSpeed Insights and compare the field data where it exists. A failing metric on the firm’s page that passes on the competitor’s is a fix to schedule; details are in Core Web Vitals for Nashville law firm sites.
  • Attorney profiles: compare the competitor’s lawyer pages with the firm’s for named authorship, admissions, practice history, publications and speaking. Google says “E-E-A-T itself isn’t a specific ranking factor” (Google’s helpful content guidance), so this comparison shows what a reader sees about the lawyers’ experience and trustworthiness, not a score Google computes. What those pages should contain is in E-E-A-T for Nashville law firms.

Step 6: Turn the Findings Into One or Two Actions

Write each finding as a gap and a fix, then rank them by how likely each is to matter and how hard each is to close:

Finding Gap type Fix Effort
Competitor's primary category matches the query; ours is broader Profile relevance Change primary category Low
Their page explains fees and the Tennessee filing deadline; ours does not Content Add both sections Medium
They have links from two local nonprofits they sponsor Links Sponsorship with a marked link Medium

For example, imagine a Nashville family law firm that finds the competitor above it uses a family law category while its own profile uses a general law firm category, and that the competitor’s practice page explains the divorce process step by step. The category change takes minutes and the content addition a few weeks; those two go first, and the link gap waits.

Each finding is a difference between two firms, not proof that the difference causes the ranking gap; Google does not publish how it weighs these factors, and results move by location and over time. Pick the one or two findings that look most likely to matter and cost the least to address, act on them, and rerun Step 1 from the same locations after a quarter to see whether the lists changed.