Cites both rulebooks

Practice Area Pages Fail Rank

7 min read

  • 7 sections
  • 7 sources cited

When a practice area page fails to rank, the first thing to check is whether it answers the questions a person asks before hiring a lawyer for that kind of matter. Pages that fail that check describe the firm instead of the process, the fees, the time frame and the law of the place where the case will be filed. Length is a symptom of that gap, not its cause.

What the Hennessey Digital Study Measured

A figure quoted in law firm SEO articles comes from Hennessey Digital’s 2022 State of Law Firm Website Rankings. Its methodology is published: the study looked at organic listings of legal websites in the 200 largest U.S. cities, and “Page content and page speed tests were conducted on 15,786 unique landing pages under 7,711 distinct domain names.” It also says: “All data was pulled, compiled, and tested in October 2021.”

Its two headline findings are: “Each of the top 10 sites listed on page 1 of the SERP have an average of 2,000 words per page,” and “The minimum word count for position 1 was 1,324 words.”

Read with its date and scope, the study describes what ranked for competitive legal searches in large U.S. markets in October 2021. It shows that the pages that ranked were long; it does not show that length made them rank. Google’s own guidance on helpful content lists “Are you writing to a particular word count because you’ve heard or read that Google has a preferred word count?” among the questions that point to content made for search engines rather than people (Google’s helpful content guidance). The useful reading of the 2,000-word average is that answering a client’s real questions about a practice area takes space, not that a page should be padded to a target.

The Four Answers a Ranking Practice Page Gives

Process. One question a person looking for a personal injury lawyer has is what happens after the first call: intake, investigation, the insurance claim, a lawsuit if one is filed, discovery, settlement talks, trial. A page that walks through those stages, and says which ones are common in the firm’s own cases, gives the reader something a brochure page does not.

Fees. A page can explain whether the firm works on contingency, hourly or flat fees and what the client pays if the case is lost. Tennessee’s RPC 7.1 treats this as a communication about the lawyer’s services; its Comment [6] permits publishing “the basis on which the lawyer’s fees are determined,” and RPC 7.1(a) treats a statement as misleading if it “omits a fact necessary to make the statement considered as a whole not materially misleading” (Board of Professional Responsibility’s copy of RPC 7). A line such as “no fee unless we win” raises the obvious follow-up question of who pays case costs if the case is lost; the page should answer it, and the firm’s lawyers should approve the wording.

Time frame. A useful answer to “how long will this take” is a range tied to the stage that controls it, such as medical treatment finishing, a lawsuit being filed or a trial date being set, written by the lawyers who handle these cases. A number with no source is worse than no number.

Jurisdiction. This is the element that separates a Nashville page from a page that could sit on any firm’s site. For a personal injury page in Tennessee, the starting point is Tenn. Code Ann. § 28-3-104(a)(1), under which actions for “injuries to the person” must be commenced “within one (1) year after the cause of action accrued.” The same section extends that to two years in defined situations where criminal charges are brought against the person alleged to have caused the injury. A page that states the one-year rule, says when it can differ, and tells the reader to confirm the deadline for their own facts with a lawyer is both more useful and safer than a page that recites a deadline from another state. A writer who copies a two-year example from a Texas page onto a Tennessee page puts the wrong deadline in front of injured readers.

What a Weak Page Looks Like Next to a Useful One

For example, imagine two openings for the same Nashville car accident page.

The weak version: “At Smith & Associates, we provide aggressive representation for accident victims. Our experienced team fights for maximum compensation. Contact us today for a free consultation.”

A useful version: “In Tennessee, a lawsuit for injuries from a car crash generally has to be filed within one year, and the start date and exceptions depend on the facts. Below: what happens in the first weeks after a crash, how our fee works and what you would owe if the case is lost, and the stages between the first call and a settlement or trial.”

The first could belong to any firm in any state. The second tells the reader where the page applies and what they will learn, and every claim in it is one the firm can support.

Structure Depends on the Practice Area

A single template does not fit every practice.

  • Family law covers custody, divorce, child support, alimony and property division. One page that covers all of them is either very long or thin on each. A parent page with a page for each sub-service serves both the reader who wants an overview and the reader with one specific question.
  • A criminal defense reader’s first question is whether the firm handles the specific charge. One comprehensive page organized by charge type, with headings such as DUI, drug charges and assault, lets them find their section quickly; separate pages make sense where a charge has enough of its own law to fill one.
  • Personal injury divides by case type: car crashes, truck crashes, premises injuries, medical negligence, wrongful death. Each has its own rules and evidence. Before splitting, check that the new page answers a question the general page does not; two pages chasing the same search compete with each other, a problem covered in how content cannibalization affects law firm pages.

Calls to action follow the same logic. A practice page serves a reader ready to call now and a reader still researching. One option is a contact line near the top for the first reader, a second after the process and fee sections, and a final one after the full content, all pointing to the same action. This is a design choice to test on the firm’s own pages, not a rule.

On-Page Details That Help a Strong Page Get Clicked

A clear title tag states the practice and the place, for example “Personal Injury Lawyer Nashville | Smith & Associates.” A descriptive URL such as /personal-injury-lawyer/ is easier for people to read than /practice-areas/pi/; if an existing page moves to a new URL, Google recommends a permanent server-side redirect from the old address (Google’s redirect documentation). Images need alt text that says what they show, such as “attorney reviewing accident report with a client,” rather than “photo1.jpg.” None of these will carry a page that does not answer the reader’s questions.

How Many Supporting Pages a Practice Area Needs

No fixed number exists. A practical way to set one for a specific practice is to count the pages the top three ranking competitors have on the questions clients ask about that practice, then plan to cover the real questions they cover and the ones they miss.

Supporting pages help in two ways that do not depend on any theory about site-wide authority. They answer narrower questions that one practice page cannot hold, and they link to the practice page. Google says its “ranking systems are designed to work on the page level,” and that “Site-wide signals and classifiers are also used and contribute to our understanding of pages” (Google’s guide to ranking systems). The practice page still has to earn its ranking on its own content. How a cluster of supporting posts is organized around a practice page is covered in topical authority for Nashville law firms.

Supporting pages should link to the practice page with descriptive anchor text, and the practice page should link to the most important supporting pages. How that link structure builds or weakens a practice page is the subject of internal linking on Nashville law firm sites. A broader walk-through of local optimization, technical setup and content structure is in this guide on SEO for Nashville law firms.

Tracking Whether a Practice Page Is Gaining Ground

In Search Console’s Performance report, filter by the practice page’s exact URL and compare impressions and average position over successive 90-day periods. Google defines the position shown there as “the topmost position occupied by a link to your property or page in search results, averaged across all queries in which your property appeared” (Google’s explanation of impressions, position and clicks). Because it is an average across queries, also look at the position for the page’s main query on its own.

For example, imagine a page moving from an average position of 18 to 12 over a quarter for its main query: it is gaining, even before clicks follow. A page that has not moved after six months of supporting content points back to the page itself; rewrite it around the four answers above before adding more posts around it.