Cites Google

Multi-Location SEO for Nashville-Area Law Firms Without Duplicates

6 min read

  • 6 sections
  • 1 table
  • 5 sources cited

A firm with offices in Nashville and Franklin can have a page for each office, and it can also have pages for places it serves without an office, as long as each page gives the people searching there something the other pages do not. Two different Google problems sit on either side of that line. Near-identical pages are a duplication issue, which Google handles by picking one version; pages created mainly to rank for a series of similar place searches, funneling everyone to the same place, are what Google calls “doorway abuse.” Office pages and service-area pages are separate cases with separate tests, and knowing which problem a set of pages has tells the firm what to fix.

Two Problems, Two Different Consequences

Duplicate content on its own is not a penalty. Google’s SEO Starter Guide says: “Having duplicate content on your site is not a violation of our spam policies, but it can be a bad user experience and search engines might waste crawling resources on URLs that you don’t even care about,” and “It’s inefficient, but it’s not something that will cause a manual action” (Google’s SEO Starter Guide). What happens in practice is that Google chooses one URL as the main version. Its Page indexing report help says “Google doesn’t index duplicate copies of a page,” and pages it treats as duplicates appear there with labels such as “Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user” (Google’s Page indexing report help). Three near-identical office pages can end up as one indexed page and two that are not shown.

Doorway pages are a policy matter. Google’s spam policies describe doorway abuse as “when sites or pages are created to rank for specific, similar search queries,” and list among the examples “pages targeted at specific regions or cities that funnel users to one page” and “Creating substantially similar pages that are closer to search results than a clearly defined, browseable hierarchy” (Google’s spam policies). The absence of an office is not itself the test. A set of suburb pages with the same text and only the town name swapped, each sending visitors to the same contact form, fits the doorway description whether or not the firm has offices there. A page about a county the firm really serves, with that county’s courts and procedures and the lawyers who handle matters there, is a different thing.

Two Kinds of Location Page, Two Tests

Office pages describe a place a client can visit. They earn their place when they answer yes to these:

  1. Is there a real office at that address, staffed and able to receive clients?
  2. Does the page name the lawyers who work from that office?
  3. Does it give the office’s own address, phone number, hours and directions?
  4. Does it say something about practicing in that place that the other office pages do not?

Service-area pages describe a place the firm serves without an office there. They earn their place when they answer yes to these:

  1. Does the firm actually take and handle matters from that area?
  2. Does the page say plainly where the firm’s offices are, so no reader thinks there is a local office?
  3. Does it carry information specific to that area that a reader there needs, such as the county’s courts or local procedure, and that the other pages do not?
  4. Would the page still be useful to a reader if the place name were removed from the title?

An office page that fails the later questions has a duplication problem, fixed by adding the content below. A service-area page that fails questions 3 and 4 has the doorway pattern; the fix is either to give it real local substance or to fold it into one page that lists the areas the firm serves.

What Makes a Franklin Page Different From a Nashville Page

For example, imagine a firm with a downtown Nashville office and a Franklin office. The Franklin page has facts available to it that the Nashville page does not:

  • Franklin is where Williamson County’s courthouse sits, at 135 S 4th Avenue. Williamson County is part of the 21st Judicial District, and the county’s court page says: “In the 21st Judicial District there are only Chancery and Circuit Courts. Probate matters are filed in Chancery Court and criminal matters are filed in Circuit Court” (Williamson County court system). A probate or criminal defense page for the Franklin office can explain which of those courts the client’s matter goes to.
  • The lawyers based there, with their admissions and the courts where they actually appear. An office’s location does not limit which courts its lawyers practice in, so the page should list the real ones rather than assume the county.
  • Parking, building access and meeting arrangements at that office.
  • The practices the firm actually handles from that office, which may differ from downtown.

Nothing on that list requires inventing local color. Each item is a fact the firm can verify, which is also what makes the page useful to someone deciding which office to call.

A Template With Required Unique Fields

A shared structure keeps pages consistent; required fields keep them from collapsing into one page:

Section Shared across offices Required to be unique
Header and contact Layout Address, phone, hours, map
Who works here Layout Named lawyers, admissions, courts where they appear
What this office handles Firm-wide practice list Practices actually handled at this office
Local court information None The courts and procedures specific to the county
Getting here None Parking, access, directions

If a section cannot be filled with something specific to that office, leave the section out of that page rather than filling it with the same text as the others.

The Business Profile Side

The Business Profile rules are stricter than the website’s, and they turn on the office, not the page. Google’s guidelines say “If your business rents a physical mailing address but doesn’t operate out of that location, also known as a virtual office, that location isn’t eligible for a Business Profile,” and that businesses “can’t list an office at a co-working space unless that office maintains clear signage, receives customers at the location during business hours, and is staffed during business hours by your business staff” (Google’s guidelines for representing a business). The same guidelines name lawyers among “individual practitioners,” with separate rules for when a lawyer has a profile apart from the firm’s. A service-area page on the website needs no profile; an office profile needs a real office. Each real office profile should link to its own office page rather than the home page, so the profile and the page describe the same location. Setting up those profiles is covered in the Google Business Profile guide for Nashville firms, and how distance affects which office appears for a searcher in how Google chooses the map pack.

Fixing an Existing Set of Pages

  1. List every location and city page on the site, and mark each as an office page or a service-area page.
  2. Check Search Console for each page’s impressions, clicks and the queries it appears for before deciding anything; a page that already brings clients from its area is worth improving, not removing.
  3. For each office page, fill the required unique fields above.
  4. For each service-area page, add the area-specific content the second test asks for, or fold it into a single “areas we serve” page if there is nothing specific to say.
  5. When a page is folded in, redirect it only to a page that covers the same area; if no such page exists, let the old URL return a not-found response instead of sending readers somewhere unrelated.
  6. Read two pages side by side with the place names covered. If they still read the same, the work is not finished.

Where two office pages compete for the same searches even after that, the issue overlaps with content cannibalization on law firm sites.