Cites Google
Map Pack Rankings for Nashville Law Firms: How Google Chooses
- 6 sections
- 1 table
- 2 sources cited
Google says local results “are mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity,” and it describes each one on its help page for businesses (Google’s local ranking tips). Google does not publish how it weighs them against each other. What a Nashville firm can do is understand what each factor means in Google’s own words, see which parts the firm controls, and work on those in the order it can move them.
The Three Factors in Google’s Words
| Factor | Google's description | What feeds it |
|---|---|---|
| Relevance | "how well a Business Profile matches what someone is searching for" | "complete and detailed business info," including the categories the firm selects |
| Distance | "how far each business is from the customer who's searching" | The firm's actual business location, against the searcher's location |
| Prominence | "how well-known a business is" | Info "like how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have" |
Two details on the same page are worth noting. When a searcher’s location is unknown, “Google uses what it knows about their location.” And on reviews, Google says “More reviews and positive ratings can help your business’s local ranking.”
Distance: Why Results Differ Across the Metro
Google measures distance from the person searching. For a metro that runs from downtown Nashville out to Franklin and beyond, that means two people typing the same query in different neighborhoods can see different firms in the map. A firm cannot change where searchers are, and adding a wider service area to the profile does not move the business location that distance is measured from. What the firm can do is keep its location accurate, list its service area truthfully as information for clients, and make the other two factors strong enough to compete where it is.
For example, imagine a firm with a single office downtown. Its profile is competing on distance for searchers near downtown and at a disadvantage for searchers in Franklin, which is the practical case for a real second office having its own profile and its own location page. An address created only to be closer to searchers is a different matter; check Google’s guidelines for representing a business before adding any location to a profile. How firms with more than one real office handle their pages is covered in multi-location SEO for Nashville-area law firms.
Relevance: Categories, Details and the Website
Google’s category help page says plainly that “The categories you select affect your local ranking on Google” (Google’s category guidelines). The primary category should name the firm’s main practice as specifically as the list allows, with a few additional categories for other practices the firm genuinely handles. Google’s instruction is to “provide complete and detailed business info,” so hours, phone, description and services should be filled in and accurate.
The firm’s website supports relevance too. A profile that says “personal injury attorney” and links to a site whose practice pages explain personal injury cases in Tennessee is a consistent picture; a profile that links to a generic home page with no practice content is a weaker one. Setting up the profile itself is covered in the Google Business Profile guide for Nashville firms.
Prominence: Links and Reviews
Google names two inputs for prominence: how many websites link to the business and how many reviews it has, with positive ratings helping. That makes prominence a website task as much as a profile task. Google names links to the business in the same description as reviews and does not say how it weighs the two, so a firm that works only on its profile leaves part of what Google describes untouched. Ethical ways to earn those links are in link building for Nashville law firms.
Reviews come with rules a restaurant does not face. Google bans incentives and selective requests, Yelp asks businesses not to request reviews at all, and Tennessee’s confidentiality rules limit what a lawyer can say in a reply; how client reviews affect a Nashville firm’s local rankings covers all three.
An Order of Work
Google does not rank the three factors by importance, so the order below is by what a firm can change and how quickly:
- Relevance first: categories, complete details and practice pages that match the profile. These changes are within the firm’s control.
- Prominence next: a review request process that fits the rules, and links earned through real work. These build over time.
- Distance last: keep the business location and service area accurate, and add a profile only for a real office.
What to Look at When a Competitor Outranks the Firm
When another firm appears in the map and yours does not, compare the two profiles factor by factor rather than guessing:
- Relevance: their primary and additional categories against yours, and whether their website has practice pages for the search.
- Distance: where their office is relative to the searcher you are testing from.
- Prominence: their review count and rating against yours, and whether their site is linked from local organizations, publications or courts’ and bar groups’ pages.
A gap in one factor is a lead, not proof that it causes the difference: rankings move, results vary by the searcher’s location, and Google does not publish its weights. Work on the gap the firm can close, then check whether the map results change from the same search locations. A full competitor analysis, including the organic results below the map, is described in SEO competitor analysis for Nashville law firms.