Cites both rulebooks
How Client Reviews Impact Nashville Law Firm SEO Rankings
- 4 sections
- 1 table
- 7 sources cited
Reviews are a local ranking input Google names directly. Its Business Profile help page says prominence is “based on info like how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have,” and that “More reviews and positive ratings can help your business’s local ranking” (Google’s local ranking tips). For a Nashville law firm, the ranking side is the simple part. The harder part is that both collecting reviews and answering them run through Tennessee’s Rules of Professional Conduct, and in 2025 the Board of Professional Responsibility publicly censured a Tennessee lawyer over replies to Google reviews.
What Google Says Reviews Do, and What It Does Not Say
Google’s page describes local results as “mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity” and places reviews under prominence, next to links from other websites. That supports two practical statements: the number of reviews counts, and so do positive ratings.
The same page does not mention how recent reviews are, how fast they arrive, or how many platforms they come from. Claims about them come from outside Google’s description of local ranking. A firm can still care about recency for a human reason: a prospective client reading a profile sees the dates, and a profile whose newest review is three years old says something about the practice whether or not Google weighs it.
Google also tells businesses to “Respond to reviews,” saying that replying “shows that you value their feedback.” For a lawyer, that advice comes with a constraint no restaurant has, covered below.
Asking for Reviews: Google, Yelp, the FTC and RPC 7.3(f)
The rules differ by platform, and a request that is fine on Google can work against a firm on Yelp.
| Rule source | Asking clients | Offering anything in return | Asking only happy clients |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google Maps content policy | Allowed for genuine experiences, without trying to influence the rating or content | Not allowed: incentives such as payment, discounts, free goods or services | Not allowed: "selectively solicit positive reviews" |
| Yelp | "Don't ask anyone to review your business" | "Don't offer freebies, discounts, or payment in exchange for reviews" | Covered by the no-asking rule |
| FTC rule, 16 CFR 465.4 (effective October 21, 2024) | Not addressed by 465.4 | Unlawful when the incentive is conditioned on a positive or negative sentiment | Not addressed by 465.4 |
| Tennessee RPC 7.3(f) | Not addressed | No giving "anything of value" to a non-employee for recommending the lawyer, with listed exceptions | Not addressed |
The table draws on Google’s Maps user contributed content policy, Yelp’s “Don’t Ask for Reviews” page, the FTC’s final rule in the Federal Register and the current text of Tennessee’s RPC 7 published by the Board of Professional Responsibility.
Three points follow for a law firm.
First, on Google a firm may ask every client for an honest review, but it may not screen for satisfied clients first. Google’s policy also says merchants “should not require or pressure users to leave ratings or write reviews while on the premises, nor should they request that specific content be included,” which rules out scripts like “mention how fast we settled your case.”
Second, Yelp asks businesses not to request reviews at all and says that “Proactively asking for reviews may hurt your Yelp rating.” A review request email that lists Google and Yelp side by side is following one platform’s rules and breaking the other’s.
Third, an incentive is a problem on every list. Google bans incentives for “posting any review,” the FTC rule reaches incentives tied to a sentiment, and Tennessee’s RPC 7.3(f) bars giving anything of value to a non-employee “for the purpose of recommending or securing the services of the lawyer.” Comment [10] to RPC 7.3 says a communication “contains a recommendation if it endorses or vouches for a lawyer’s credentials, abilities, competence, character, or other professional qualities.” Whether a particular review falls within 7.3(f) is a question for the Board’s Ethics Counsel, but the platform rules already answer the practical question: no gift cards, no fee discounts, no donations in exchange for a review.
Fabricated reviews, reviews written by staff, and reviews posted under a client’s name fall under RPC 8.4(c), which the Board’s RPC 7 materials describe as the prohibition on “conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation.” Google’s policy separately excludes reviews based on a conflict of interest, including “current or former employment.”
When a firm republishes reviews on its own website, they become the firm’s own advertising. RPC 7.1, Comment [3] says an accurate account of past results “may be misleading if presented so as to lead a reasonable person to form an unjustified expectation that the same results could be obtained for other clients,” so a testimonial that celebrates a settlement amount needs the same context as a results page.
Answering a Negative Review: The 2025 Tennessee Censure
On January 14, 2025, the Board of Professional Responsibility publicly censured a Hamilton County lawyer whose client in a child support modification case had posted a negative Google review. According to the Board’s release, the lawyer’s public response included “references to client’s minimal payment toward her retainer fee, a contempt action brought against client for failure to pay child support and her inability to pay, the client’s disability and disability attorney, the actual hearing date, and reference to various attorney-client communications.” The release adds that between 2015 and 2023 the lawyer had answered four other negative client reviews in ways that revealed confidential information.
The Board found violations of RPC 1.6(a) (confidentiality of information) and RPC 1.9(c) (duties to former clients), along with RPC 1.16(a)(3) and (d) for a separate withdrawal problem, and ordered three hours of CLE on client confidentiality and online and social media use.
The American Bar Association reached a similar view under the Model Rules in Formal Opinion 496 (January 13, 2021). As reported by the ABA Journal, the opinion concluded that a negative online review “is not a ‘controversy between the lawyer and the client'” for purposes of the self-defense exception, that “a public response is not reasonably necessary” even if it were, and offered one permissible response: “Professional obligations do not allow me to respond as I would wish.” An ABA opinion does not bind a Tennessee lawyer; the Tennessee censure shows the Board applying the state’s own rules to the same situation.
A Response Pattern That Keeps Google’s Advice and the Rules Together
- Reply to positive reviews with thanks that adds nothing about the matter. “Thank you for taking the time to write this” confirms nothing; “We were glad to get your settlement finished before trial” does.
- For a negative review, either do not reply or use a short statement that does not confirm the person was a client, does not describe any matter, and does not argue.
- Never mention fees, dates, outcomes, health, family or anything said in a consultation, even when the reviewer has already mentioned it.
- Keep the reply decision with a lawyer, not with the marketing vendor who manages the profile.
Reviews are part of a larger profile; how categories, services and the rest of a Business Profile are set up is covered in the Google Business Profile guide for Nashville firms, and how reviews sit next to relevance and distance in how Google chooses the map pack.
The ranking benefit of reviews comes from count and rating, and every step a firm takes to grow them, from the request email to the reply, has to fit Google’s policy and Tennessee’s confidentiality and advertising rules first.
General information about Tennessee’s lawyer advertising and confidentiality rules as of October 2026, not legal advice. For guidance on your own facts, the Board of Professional Responsibility’s Ethics Counsel takes inquiries from Tennessee attorneys.